Tuesday, January 06, 2009

More On Skyfire

I wrote previously about what I thought about smartphone-only browser Skyfire's chances to make any money for its investors, but at that point I hadn't properly used it. I just did, on a Nokia E61 (3G S60 smartphone with QWERTY keyboard, not very nice to use itself but modern and relatively high spec), and I can't say I was overly impressed.
In theory it has the best AJAX support of any browser - in practice it proved why AJAX is not fit for mobile UIs yet. I ran a quick test on Flickr, the kind of site that ought to be in the standard test suite for web 2.0 browsers I'd have thought, and tried to tag a photo (which uses some funky AJAX, for those that don't have Flickr accounts).
It took me about 2 minutes to navigate through to a photo - various clicks did not do what I expected (ie. what they do on a desktop) - during which time I decided that the zooming system is quite clever, but ultimately quite annoying and not as good as a nicely reformatted page which takes account of the screen size (like Webkit / Opera) or indeed anywhere near as nice as a pinch and zoom iPhone affair.
Despite the browser emulating a mouse pointer (I always dislike this as a UI system with handsets that don't have proper pointing hardware), CSS rollovers weren't shown at all which is a shame as the new Flickr home page makes very good use of them when showing you recent events.
On reaching the photo I wanted to tag, I clicked on the 'Add a tag' link and waited. And waited. (A simultaneous test on my laptop on another photo suggested it was not Flickr slowing things down). After 4-5 seconds a textbox appeared, I entered the tag, clicked 'Add' and waited several more seconds. Then the tag appeared.
So on the one hand, Skyfire handled the AJAX as well as it could within the constraints of the handset. But on the other, whilst faster than reloading whole pages, the AJAX experience wasn't exactly super quick and responsive - something I find essential for me to bother using AJAXy features on a real PC.
The AJAX speed isn't Skyfire's fault of course, it just shows the limitations of the medium - many years after 3G was launched it still isn't widespread and still isn't fast. Maybe HSDPA will work better, but the whole experience didn't convince me that I want to do anything serious in a mobile browser any year soon...

5 Comments:

Anonymous james (mjelly) said...

Yeah tried it out quickly - they have a long way to go to be better than opera mini. Is having ajax and flash support really that important at the moment for mobile internet?

It does seem to have some fans though and they are great for the market as a whole, even if they never make any money back for the VCs.

10:55 am

 
Anonymous OpenCart customization Ahmedabad said...

wonderful points altogether, you just gained a fresh reader. What would you suggest in regards to your put up which you manufactured a few days back? Any favourable?

- PHP Web Application Development Ahmedabad | Shopping Cart Development Ahmedabad | Shopping Cart Applications Developers Ahmedabad

6:50 am

 
Blogger 小熊小熊 said...

gucci outlet
cheap oakley sunglasses
michael kors outlet
air max shoes
chanel bags
copy watches
coach outlet
louis vuitton
toms promo code
nfl jerseys
coach outlet online
louis vuitton outlet
replica watches
fendi bags
true religion outlet
abercrombie
prada uk outlet
abercrombie fitch
louis vuitton uk outlet
coach outlet
fake oakley sunglasses
tory burch shoes
coach outlet
christian louboutin outlet
soccer shoes
burberry sale
air max uk
knockoff watches
michael kors outlet
kevin durant shoes 2015
louis vuitton
celine bag
louis vuitton
ed hardy outlet store
kate spade
jordan 6s
20150724xiong

10:25 am

 
Blogger Nike Free said...

christian louboutin 2016
christian louboutin sale
jordan 11 legend blue
cheap jordans
new jordan shoes
Air Jordan 4 Alternate 89
coach outlet online coach factory outlet
coach outlet stores
2015 michael kors outlet
Michael Kors Store
michael kors jet set tote
michael kors sale
michael kors uk
Michael Kors Outlet Online Store
Nike Basketball Shoes
kd 7
nike air max
nike air max 2014
nike free 3.0
nike free run womens
Red Bottom Shoes For Women
christian louboutin outlet
mbt
mbt canada
fitflop.com
fitflop sandals
www.2016nikeairhuaraches.com
Huaraches Nike

2:11 am

 
Blogger Nike Free said...

www.2016nikeairhuaraches.com
All Balck Huarache
christian louboutin store
christian louboutin shoes
cheap jordans for sale
jordan 11 legend blue
Jordan 11 Concord
Jordan Retro 8 Concord
coach outlet store online
coach outlet stores
michael kors purses
2015 michael kors outlet
michael kors wallets
Michael Kors Factory Outlet
michael kors factory outlet
michael kors outlet online store 49.00 outlet
Nike Basketball Shoes
kobe shoes
nike air max thea
nike outlet
nike free run
nike free 5.0
Red Bottom Shoes
louboutin outlet
mbt usa
mbt Shoes
fitflops
fitflop.com

2:13 am

 

Post a Comment

<< Home