Friday, November 07, 2008

iSkoot Pull Fast One on VCs

Congratulations today must go to iSkoot, "the company that brought Skype to mobile phones" (well technically, only one of the companies to do that as Skype themselves have done it too, as have a whole raft of other companies with even shallower business models than Skype itself).

They have now raised a $19m third round of funding from some people in suits, bringing their total fleecing investment up to $33m.

The purpose for this cash injection was to build an applications platform for AT&T. Presumably AT&T want this platform so much, they won't pay for it - but presumably the suits think it is worth at least $19m, and probably a lot more. AT&T have 71.4m customers right now, and operators usually give say a 30-40% revenue share to the people who do the work, so $19m would need $47.5m in sales, which is 66 cents per customer. If you wanted to also beat the interest rate a bank would give you on the same cash, you'd probably need to up that sale price; if you wanted a profit (shock, horror, etc) you'd want to clear over a dollar from every single AT&T customer.

Decide for yourself how ambitious that sales target is, given the usual proportion of customers who download premium applications for their phones on any given network (excluding the early iPhone App Store goldrush, that is, which AT&T can't access).

So - what is this app platform that will generate so much revenue? It's a service to bring "social networking, email, RSS feeds and eventually services like Twitter" onto low-end phones. Right. Forgive me but isn't Twitter (aside from being pointless and loss making) already available, through the wonder of SMS (that extremely high margin data service that operators love above all others)? Are AT&T crying out for services that cannibalise those SMS revenues by generating greater use of GPRS/3G bandwidth (given away for near-free these days, but costing the operator a lot to maintain and scale infastructure)?

OK, but what about the other (more useful) services? RSS and email have been available on all feature phones for a while, and things like the GMail Java app can be used even on the pretty low-end devices.

But wait! There's a USP! iSkoot have a very special magic at their disposal which allows them to integrate deeply into every phone - "Skype, for example, is so deeply embedded in the software stack that Skype contacts are integrated directly into the phone's address book". Would you pay $1 to have your Facebook contacts added to your phone? Personally no (all the ones I know well enough to talk to on the phone are already in there), but maybe some people would. But how is this deep deep deep integration achieved?

Well, the conventional way on the GSM range of handsets supplied by AT&T would be to use the JSR75 PIM API from inside JavaME, available (to any developer) on most of the mid- to high- end devices (and probably a few of the low-end ones too). Not really a $19m USP then...

Could it be something more? Well, iSkoot do appear to have done some of the customisation of the Skype-branded Amoi launched on 3 in some territories a while back. V1 was pretty flaky but a good effort if you have a high tolerance for bugs in your phone's UI - I haven't tried V2 yet... this does indeed feature a lot of customisation, achieved through a lot of customisation effort. This much customisation could be ordered by an operator with AT&T's clout, though doing it to their range are off-the-shelf Nokias, SEs, Motos, Samsungs etc would slow down handset launches, increase the risk of bugs and recalls (this has happened to Orange a few times with their simple front page rewrites) and cost a hell of a lot. iSkoot may well be able to do the work, but would AT&T want them to? It would appear AT&T at the very least don't want to pay for it...

Of course, I'm sure I'm not seeing the big picture here, every operator in the world will need this so there's got to be a hockey stick graph in the PPT somewhere - but, as most of the companies like Facebook are bringing themselves to mobile quite happily, Twitter is custom designed for SMS, etc etc, I remain uncertain why the whole world will need this $19m platform.

Please, someone, show me the light! Or if that is impractical, send me $19m to the usual address and I'll see if I can come up with something similarly world beating...


Anonymous Anonymous said...

This is really interesting, You're a very skilled blogger. I have joined your feed and look forward to seeking more of your fantastic post. Also, I have shared your website in my social networks!

My web blog; binary options trading strategy

2:23 pm

Blogger Unknown said...

gucci outlet
cheap oakley sunglasses
michael kors outlet
air max shoes
chanel bags
copy watches
coach outlet
louis vuitton
toms promo code
nfl jerseys
coach outlet online
louis vuitton outlet
replica watches
fendi bags
true religion outlet
prada uk outlet
abercrombie fitch
louis vuitton uk outlet
coach outlet
fake oakley sunglasses
tory burch shoes
coach outlet
christian louboutin outlet
soccer shoes
burberry sale
air max uk
knockoff watches
michael kors outlet
kevin durant shoes 2015
louis vuitton
celine bag
louis vuitton
ed hardy outlet store
kate spade
jordan 6s

10:25 am

Blogger Unknown said...

mbt shoes online
mbt outlet
fitflops sale
fitflop sandals
Nike Kobe 9
christian louboutin
red sole shoes
jordans shoes
jordan 13
Jordan Retro 8 Concord
jordan 11
coach outlet
coach outlet store online
michael kors outlet
michael kors bags
Michael Kors Sale
michael kors tote
Michael Kors Outlet Online Store
michael kors uk
kd shoes
jordans 11
nike air max 90
nike air max thea
nike free 5.0 womens
nike free flyknit
black christian louboutin
christian louboutin online

2:12 am

Blogger Unknown said...

Andhra Pradesh Integrated Common Entrance Test.Know all about APICET exam like result, syllabus, exam pattern, eligibility criteria, important dates, application details, counseling, discussions
ICET 2017 online Application

6:33 am

Blogger Unknown said...

Get information about Passport Police Verification Process And Status Pre-Police Verification.
passport police verification status

1:03 pm

Blogger Unknown said...

Here you can get the SBI General Insurance features, benefits & premium.
Click here for more information

1:13 pm

Blogger Unknown said...

SBI Mutual Fund offers various mutual funds schemes such as Hybrid schemes, Equity schemes, Debt schemes, etc. to know the details about SBI Systematic Investment Plan.
Go here

7:11 am

Blogger Unknown said...

Price list of Class 10 Memory cards in India with specifications and features available here.
memory card price

11:49 am

Blogger Unknown said...

Phoenix is one of best Kodi addons which allows you to watch Movies, Sports, Live TV etc. Check the process to install Phoenix Kodi
Phoenix Kodi Addon

11:57 am

Blogger Unknown said...

NEET Medical Entrance Exam Hall Tickets are released,Click here for mmore details and download the admit cards.
NEET Exam admit Card

8:53 am

Blogger Unknown said...

Digital Camera price list 2017 for sale in India. You can check various Digital Cameras and the latest prices, compare prices.
Go here

8:25 am

Blogger Unknown said...

get the complete details about lic merchant login. For more click here
LIC Login

8:33 am

Blogger Unknown said...

Check out PPF Calculator For regular PPF Investment, Know More about SBI PPF account calculator.
click here

6:34 am

Blogger Unknown said...

Here you can get the complete information about zero size diet plan. For more click here
zero size diet plan

12:07 pm

Blogger Unknown said...

Find the best drones for aerial videography and photography. Get the complete information about the drones
Best Drones For Sale

1:02 pm

Blogger Unknown said...

Click here for best teeth whitening treatments.
best teeth whitening treatments

1:32 pm

Blogger Unknown said...

Lic login registration for customers, agents, merchants, New lic customer
lic of india login

10:36 am

Blogger Unknown said...

To find out detailed dish tv customer care toll free numbers, service center details, registered email-id's and official address of dish tv.
Click here

10:39 am

Blogger Unknown said...

Click here to Check the Details of ICICI bank Fixed Deposit Rates, ICICI FD Interest Rates with Latest Schemes in 2017.
ICICI FD calculator

11:32 am

Blogger Unknown said...

Click here to Download the State Bank of India Probationary Officer Previous Year Question Papers with solutions.
SBI po Previous papers

6:19 am

Blogger Unknown said...

Get all the information about Upcoming Bank Exams 2017 like IBPS PO, SBI PO and clerk about Syllabus with Exam Pattern, Question Papers, Click here.
Bank Syllabus

6:25 am

Blogger Unknown said...

TS POLYCET Results 2017 available. Polytechnic Common Entrance Exam 2017 and download the Telangana CEEP Rank card 2017.
Click here for more information

1:51 pm

Blogger Unknown said...

click here to know your Maturity amount and interest rates by using the Fixed Deposit Calculator.
FD calculator

1:44 pm

Blogger Unknown said...

click here to Know about PPF Calculator and learn where and many types of PPF Maturity Calculators.
ppf calculator

7:29 am

Blogger Unknown said...

Latest Best Semi Automatic Washing Machine in India is here. Check Top 10 Semi Automatic Washing Machine Price List, Capacity, Features.
Best semi automatic washing machine

12:04 pm

Blogger Unknown said...

The White Screen of Death is a well-documented WordPress error which can stem from a number of different causes.
Click here to know more

1:15 pm

Blogger Unknown said...

List of Whirlpool Washing Machine in India with their lowest online prices. Find the best washing machines by click here.
whirlpool washing machine price

7:06 am

Blogger Unknown said...

Here we given full details and price of best and popular refrigerator models in India under Rs. 15000/-, for more details check here
double door refrigerator price below 15000

12:27 pm

Anonymous Obat Keputihan Alami said...

thank you for joining us. his article is very helpful

Obat Maag Alami
Cara Mengobati Hematuria
Obat Penambah Berat Badan
Cara Mengobati Penyakit Kista
Cara Mengobati Sesak Napas Alami
Cara Mengobati Penyakit Gagal Jantung

2:56 am

Blogger ragini verma said...

LIC Merchant is the one stop Destination for Partners and Life Insurance Agents of Life Insurance Corporation of India.
LIC Merchant Login

10:34 am

Blogger Adom said...

5:22 pm

Blogger Sudesh N said...

Fantastic and Thank you so much. I really loved this article
LIC Merchant is the official website for Life Insurance Agents and Partners of Life Insurance Corporation of India.
LIC Merchant

4:30 am

Blogger yanmaneee said...

lebron 15 shoes
off white hoodie
nike air max
supreme new york
off white hoodie
kobe basketball shoes
jordan 13
cheap jordans
adidas stan smith shoes

10:01 am


Post a Comment

<< Home